Budget 2021: cautious silence between a rock and a hard place

National Treasury found itself cornered by a triple threat. Taxpayers are fed up, ratings agencies bring consistent downgrades, and yet fragile political alliances refuse to allow the radical change we need to implement. At a glance, the result is a risk-averse strategy that fails to address root causes of our problems.

Help us oppose corruption

OUTA is standing up against government corruption and mismanagement. Our work is made possible though donations by our paying supporters.

25/02/2021 10:21:08

Budget 2021: Cautious silence between a rock and a hard place 

National Treasury found itself cornered by a triple threat. Taxpayers are fed up, ratings agencies bring consistent downgrades, and yet fragile political alliances refuse to allow the radical change we need to implement. At a glance, the result is a risk-averse strategy that fails to address root causes of our problems.

Budget 2021 holds the much-needed line on fiscal consolidation in the face of public service wage demands, but continues to avoid addressing South Africa’s fundamental problems.

The size of the deficit is less than feared, but it is still vast and must be filled with increased debt, which South Africa borrows at premium rates and puts our country in more debt.

“The recession we found ourselves in a year ago along with the Covid-19 pandemic and strict lockdown regulations has taken its toll. Though the budget brings some relief, it is also a headache as we see years ahead of money being sunk into failing SOEs that should be restructured or closed,” says Julius Kleynhans, OUTA Executive Manager: Public Governance Division.

There were encouraging aspects.

Government appears to have taken note of the anger from taxpayers over suggestions of tax increases after years of unrestrained waste and looting, so backed down on last year’s proposal to increase taxes and on recent hints of increases to pay for the Covid-19 vaccine.

Instead, there is a little tax relief for individuals and businesses which is welcome.

Government has found sufficient vaccine funding, although this indicates a two-year rollout.

SARS gets an extra R3bn over three years for a new unit to ensure tax compliance of those with wealth and complex financial arrangements. The Department of Justice gets R1.8bn to combat crime and corruption, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the money will be applied where it’s needed most.

Unfortunately, there is a long and difficult road ahead. Much of this Budget is treading water.

Debt-service costs are increasing as a percentage of the budget. Although this is increasing at a lower rate than previously predicted – which will reassure the ratings agencies – the size of the total debt is heading for an enormous R5.23 trillion by 2023/24. Those debt costs are slowly edging out social spending. In 2019/20, debt-service costs (R205bn) were less than spending on health (R222bn) and social development (R285bn), but by 2023/24, debt-service costs (R339bn) will be higher than spending on both health (R245bn) and social development (R325bn). Of course, such figures aren’t sustainable.

While the pandemic lockdowns hit the poor hardest, with the big job losses at lower levels, many of these were not paid enough to be taxpayers. However, the Budget shows that over the last two years, the number of registered taxpaying taxpayers has dropped each year. In the last year, there are 12% fewer of those paying tax on more than R1m a year, many perhaps having left South Africa.

Taken together, crushing debt and fragile revenue sources means the status quo cannot last long.

While the Covid-19 social relief of distress grant is extended a little longer to the end of April, the increases on the regular grants are merely token gestures and there is a long-term loss in value in the grants. This is very bad news for those who rely on it, but indeed, as Minister Mboweni says, the government is not swimming in cash, and our limits are hardening.

The Department of Tourism has reprioritised R540 million over the medium term to establish the Tourism Equity Fund and support tourism recovery. While we welcome the support for this crucial sector, we are concerned that this may mean that the department will acquire equity stakes in tourism enterprises, if businesses must sell a stake in their enterprise to get help.

The fundamental problems are barely tackled.

Failing SOEs continue to haunt the Budget, and the list of their problems makes dismal reading. Rather than seeing expedited structural reforms, we see annual increases and ad hoc injections of capital from the fiscus to unviable institutions.

Eskom is still on almost perpetual life-support from government (R56bn in 2020/21, R31.7bn in 2021/22) and is also borrowing more to meet debt payments. The SAA bailout of R16.4bn over three years announced in last year’s budget remains but, as OUTA predicted, SAA now needs more: R19.3bn, although this isn’t (yet) in the budget. The Land Bank is bailed out. The desperate Denel is “discussing” its situation with government. SABC, with arguably a more important public mandate than SAA, is retrenching staff. ACSA is selling non-core assets to make ends meet; but in a poorly timed move, Arts and Culture this week announced two airports would be renamed.

Government capacity is still lacking at every level, which affects every programme from vaccine rollout and early childhood development programmes to mega infrastructure projects.

While government grapples with the remuneration bill by trying to reduce the annual increase – an essential move – there seems little will to weed out the rot in the public service: where are the dismissals of those who oversaw the looting, those who dishonestly claimed Covid-relief grants and those whose programmes fail to deliver year after year? Expecting those who connived in corruption and mismanagement to get South Africa out of this mess is unrealistic. Granular budgets need to get real, and National Treasury cannot rely on individuals who caused our financial woes to provide solutions.

We hope the new National Implementation Framework towards the Professionalisaton of the Public Service, which is still in process, will help move the public service further towards delivering value for money. The finalisation of the Public Procurement Bill is urgent, but civil society has raised concerns about its limited provision for public transparency. If NERSA and its shocking decision-making is the model, a new central procurement Regulator on the horizon doesn’t exactly inspire confidence.

Local government finances remain a major concern. There doesn’t seem to be a solution on the table to the municipal debt problem, and a doubling down on “own revenue” is being put forward. As part of the fiscal consolidation policies over the medium term, transfers to local government are reduced by R19.4bn. Municipalities are already implementing wage increases most cannot afford, so these cuts will add to the pressure. The solution is not for municipalities to hunt for other sources of revenue but to improve the management of revenue streams they already have and to stop abusing our rates and taxes.

While there are nuggets of real value in this Budget, such as the tax breaks and vaccine funding, it is yet another Budget which does not engage with the political problems and barriers which have plagued South Africa for years. We need to go back to the drawing board in our public sector expenditure, and civil society must be at the forefront of such a renewal – rather than keeping the wrong hands at the till.

A soundclip with comment by OUTA's Parliamentary Engagement Manager, Matt Johnston, is here.


Picture: OUTA